This year the global kidney community made acute kidney
injury (AKI) the theme of World Kidney Day. This was a significant and
important moment in raising the profile of such a common, harmful, and
avoidable condition. At the Renal Association and forthcoming British Renal Society
meeting AKI research is prominent and the NICE guideline on AKI is now out for consultation
– what are you doing about it?
The day before World Kidney Day, in a prescient step, the
Government appointed US patient safety expert Professor Donald Berwick to lead
a newly created National Advisory Group on the Safety of Patients in England.
Berwick’s Group has been set up in the wake of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry to make “zero-harm” a reality and take
‘serious and profound action’ to minimize patient harm. As
his group of 14 US and UK experts sit down to take on this challenge there will no doubt be a number of competing
issues jostling for priority on their agenda. However, despite, being the cause of
at least 12,000 avoidable deaths a year, an average of 32 a day, it is unlikely
that AKI will be at the top of this group’s agenda.
This would be a mistake and a missed opportunity. AKI is the “miner’s canary” of the quality of basic and
safe care. It is the reliable biomedical counterpart to the “cultural barometer”
called for by the Right Honourable Robert Francis QC’s in his second report on
the Mid Staffordshire Trust failures of care. It is the one single measure which will tell us if we
are making improvements from the nadir of Mid-Staffordshire.
AKI is silent but deadly. It is estimated to affect up to one in five,
or 20% of all emergency admissions to hospital, often as a result of primary
illness such as pneumonia, diarrhoea or a heart attack. That’s over half a million people a year in the
UK of whom somewhere between 62,000 and
210,000 people die with AKI, which is almost 200 times the number dying of a
MRSA.
Up
to a third of cases of AKI and thousands of deaths could be avoided through the
provision of basic medical care, including reviewing medication, ensuring that
patients are hydrated, treating infections promptly and ensuring consultant review
within 12 hours. However, current care of patients is variable and often poor.
The 2009 NCEPOD report Adding Insult to Injury highlighted failures of
basic care of those with Acute Kidney Injury (AKI), with only half being found
to be adequate.
In the age of the ‘Nicholson Challenge’, there is also a significant
financial imperative to make AKI a political priority. AKI prolongs hospital
stay by a multiplication factor of over 2.5 and costs the NHS £1.2 Billion.
That’s the same cost as the whole of the chronic dialysis and kidney transplant
programmes and greater
than prostate, bowel and lung cancer combined. Estimates suggest AKI prevention
could save the NHS between £130 to 186m a year, which would pay the full
staff costs of a moderate sized district general hospital.
The
challenge is how we can take a condition that is seen as a complex, specialist,
renal issue and make it a mainstream health priority. The good news is that as
a renal community, we are uniquely well positioned to make this happen, and in
our experience with CKD, we have the roadmap.
Last
year was the decade anniversary of the KDOQI CKD Guidelines,
which were the first step in a ten year transformation of the political, public
and policy profile of kidney disease. Whilst retaining the prioritisation on
improvement in dialysis and transplantation, a wider focus was achieved,
getting kidney disease understood within the wider-vascular agenda and making
it an issue for all health care professionals. We transformed CKD beyond
recognition lets now do the same for AKI.
What
can we learn for AKI? NICE Guidelines for AKI, launched for consultation on
World Kidney Day, and the prioritization of AKI in the Department of Health’s
Cardiovascular Disease Outcomes Strategy are significant steps for raising
awareness and influencing practice to tackle variations in care.
However,
they will not be enough alone. Indeed, the AKI guidelines are aimed at
non-specialists in the NHS and it is worth remembering that we already have
NICE Guidelines 50 on the recognition of acutely ill patients in
hospital, which were published five years ago.Unfortunately, sometimes when an issue is everyone’s business, it quickly
becomes no one’s business.
The last few months have been a tough time for the NHS. Not only have we
just gone through the largest reorganisation since its inception in 1948 but at
the same time the issue of how we in the NHS treat vulnerable patients, not
only at Mid Staffs, has rightly come under scrutiny. AKI largely
affects the vulnerable. The same people who often don’t get adequate hydration
or nutrition in hospital. The same group for whom compassion, dignity and
respect is often lacking.
AKI is the safety concern for the NHS and we will need broad
engagement across specialties to drive improvements. But we will not achieve
the transformational change required simply by commissioning alone. First and
foremost, healthcare professionals across the NHS need to understand what the
kidney does, why it is important, and how it can be protected. We will all need
to ‘think kidney’ as a matter of course.
There has been a lot of nurse and health-care assistant bashing but
culture is set from the boardroom. As General Slim once said “there aren’t any bad
soldiers only poor officers.” In my experience nearly everyone in the NHS gets
up in the morning to do a good job. So let’s move away from blaming whole
segments of the health care professions but at the same time acknowledge that
the system isn’t the Commissioning Board, the new PFI trust buildings, the
rules and regulations – it’s you and I, it’s the staff of the NHS and yes we
need to up our game as multiprofessional teams and help address these failures.
Let’s start with AKI. Let’s use the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges
multiprofessional skills and competencies framework on all our wards. If you haven’t introduced eAlerts for AKI in
your hospital what on earth are you waiting for? If AKI isn’t a board priority in your
hospital, if it’s not in the quality accounts, why not? But most of all, what can you personally do
to help stop people dying of AKI?
My message to the kidney community as I step down from the role of Renal
Tsar for the country is thank you for all your support, together we are doing a
good job for patients and families with CKD.
Now is the time to turn our attention to AKI.
